Favorites

These are the bottles our customers come back for again and again: nine oils and balsamics, led by Tuscan Herb, Traditional Dark, Cranberry Pear and Sicilian Lemon. Find something for tonight's dinner, a gift for a friend or the bottle that becomes your own favorite.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Enjoyed by thousands of happy customers
Collection of favorite The Little Shop of Olive Oils gourmet products, including Tuscan Herb olive oil and traditional dark balsamic vinegar with fresh olives and herbs.

Fresh, flavor-forward

First cold press, taste first

Small-batch, family-owned

Franklin, MA - ships nationwide

Made for every day

Salads, dressings and cooking

Free shipping over $100

Continental US

Skip to results list
14 items

Filter

Customers are saying

4.98 ★ (552)
Verified

Find Your Favorite

Choose by What You Cook

Tuscan Herb Premium Olive Oil and Traditional Dark Balsamic Vinegar are perfect for bread dipping, vegetables and marinades. Garlic Premium Olive Oil with Sicilian Lemon White Balsamic Vinegar brightens salads and fish.

Butter Premium Olive Oil is a fun swap on popcorn and potatoes, and it's lovely with Gravenstein Apple White Balsamic on roasted sweet potatoes. Vermont Maple Dark Balsamic is a natural match for squash.

Make It Your Own

Start simple so you can taste the flavor. Drizzle it over warm vegetables, spoon it on tomatoes or dip a piece of bread.

Then try a pairing. Cranberry Pear is lovely on a salad, and Mission Fig is a cheese board's best friend.

Favorites FAQs

What should I try first?

Pick one oil and one balsamic that match meals you already love. Tuscan Herb and Traditional Dark are a great start.
Do I need to be a good cook?

Not at all. Most of these taste wonderful as a simple drizzle or dip.
Can you help me choose a gift?

Of course. Tell us what they love to eat and your budget, and we'll suggest a pairing or sampler.

Explore more